Home » Forum » Topics

Is a cash offer really better than a financed one in this market?

real estateselling a homehome buying
avatar
Rostislav_55
Joined:
10.06.2021
Posts: 2124
Topic Starter
16.04.2025 22:29
I'm currently in the process of selling my home and I've received two very similar offers. One is from a buyer who is paying cash, but the other buyer is offering about $5,000 more while using a conventional mortgage. I've always heard that cash is king, but the difference in price is making me hesitate. Is it worth taking the lower cash offer just to avoid the risk of the financing falling through? I'm curious to hear how others have handled this dilemma recently.
12 replies in this topic
avatar
Oliviya_T
Joined:
28.12.2022
Posts: 978
20.04.2025 22:51
Honestly, $5,000 is not enough of a spread to risk a financing contingency in this market. I'd take the cash offer every single time.
avatar
Toni_M
Joined:
19.02.2024
Posts: 537
18.06.2025 11:12
In reply to a previous post
I agree with the first poster. Financing can fall through at the last minute for a hundred different reasons, and the stress isn't worth five grand.
avatar
Poli_H
Joined:
15.12.2021
Posts: 698
04.07.2025 00:26
It really depends on how solid the buyer's pre-approval is. Have your agent call their lender to see how far along they are in the underwriting process.
avatar
Fabi_W
Joined:
08.11.2022
Posts: 882
13.07.2025 04:31
In reply to a previous post
Exactly what @user3 said. If the lender has already gone through full underwriting, the risk is minimal. Don't leave money on the table if the mortgage buyer is rock solid.
avatar
BqlaVrana
Joined:
07.09.2023
Posts: 1691
22.07.2025 14:40
I sold my place last year and took the financed offer because it was $15k higher. It was a bit nerve-wracking, but it closed without a hitch. $5k is a toss-up though.
avatar
Marius_C
Joined:
28.02.2020
Posts: 763
01.08.2025 04:44
If you take the financed offer, just make sure your contract has a tight appraisal gap clause. That's usually where these deals die, not just the financing.
avatar
misho_777
Joined:
20.04.2023
Posts: 508
03.08.2025 10:43
In reply to a previous post
I'm with you, OP. Everyone says 'cash is king,' but in reality, a conventional buyer with 20% down is often just as safe as a cash buyer.
avatar
Aleks_K
Joined:
14.05.2021
Posts: 1967
08.09.2025 22:47
In reply to a previous post
Are you in a rush to move? If you need the certainty to close on your next house, take the cash. If you can afford for the deal to drag out or even fail, take the higher bid.
avatar
Iva_R
Joined:
17.09.2020
Posts: 1849
06.10.2025 22:47
I’ve seen too many deals fall apart due to hidden financing issues. Take the cash offer and sleep easy at night knowing the deal is done.
avatar
monika_p
Joined:
15.02.2022
Posts: 1583
16.12.2025 16:39
In reply to a previous post
Don't forget to factor in the cost of carrying your home for an extra 30-45 days if the financed deal closes later than the cash one would. That $5k might disappear quickly.
avatar
Poli_H
Joined:
26.12.2021
Posts: 545
31.12.2025 14:49
I took a financed offer last month and the buyer's loan was denied two days before closing. Never again. Cash only for me from now on.
avatar
robert_d
Joined:
26.11.2025
Posts: 437
13.02.2026 06:47
In reply to a previous post
Wow, that's a nightmare scenario. Definitely reinforces why people prioritize cash offers, even if they're slightly lower.

Want to join the discussion?

Log in to your account to post a reply in this thread.