Home » Forum » Topics

Has anyone successfully appealed their property tax assessment?

real estateproperty taxeshomeowners
avatar
Georgi_Pro
Joined:
10.11.2021
Posts: 1373
Topic Starter
28.01.2025 05:11
I just received my new property tax assessment in the mail, and the valuation seems significantly higher than what I could actually sell the house for in this market. I've looked up a few comparable sales in my neighborhood, and they definitely don't support the jump in value the county is claiming. Has anyone here gone through the formal appeal process before? I'm wondering if it's worth the time and effort to fight it, or if the county board usually just denies these requests anyway. Any tips on what kind of evidence is most effective would be greatly appreciated.
14 replies in this topic
avatar
Fabi_W
Joined:
20.09.2022
Posts: 756
23.02.2025 14:07
I did this two years ago and managed to get my assessment lowered by about 15%. It is definitely worth the effort if you have solid data.
avatar
mati_123
Joined:
12.04.2024
Posts: 532
27.02.2025 21:10
In reply to a previous post
Definitely pull those comparable sales reports. The county assessors usually rely on automated models that don't account for specific property conditions.
avatar
Toni_M
Joined:
09.05.2020
Posts: 294
31.03.2025 04:48
Has anyone tried hiring a professional appraiser to help with the appeal? Is it worth the cost?
avatar
ObiknovenChovek
Joined:
20.05.2020
Posts: 2214
06.04.2025 00:34
In reply to a previous post
I hired an appraiser last time. It cost me $400, but it saved me over $1,200 in taxes for the year, so it paid for itself pretty quickly.
avatar
SamoPitam
Joined:
28.08.2024
Posts: 1071
15.06.2025 07:03
Be prepared for a long wait. The board is usually swamped with appeals during assessment season.
avatar
ekspert_forum
Joined:
26.01.2024
Posts: 375
07.07.2025 09:57
In reply to a previous post
Make sure you include photos if your house has any deferred maintenance or damage. That really helps sway the board.
avatar
Goshko_Bolo
Joined:
15.09.2022
Posts: 2337
08.08.2025 10:04
In reply to a previous post
I tried once and they denied me immediately because my comps were in a different school district. Make sure your comps are hyper-local.
avatar
chicho_savet
Joined:
05.09.2024
Posts: 1534
31.08.2025 09:35
It's all about the 'market value' definition. If you can prove they valued it above what a buyer would pay, you have a strong case.
avatar
robert_d
Joined:
13.06.2024
Posts: 2236
18.10.2025 23:20
Does anyone know if you can do this online, or do you have to go to the courthouse in person?
avatar
Marius_C
Joined:
10.10.2020
Posts: 854
31.10.2025 08:05
In reply to a previous post
Most counties have moved the process online now, but check your local tax assessor's website first.
avatar
Alan_K
Joined:
15.04.2021
Posts: 2137
17.12.2025 07:35
In reply to a previous post
I just sent a polite letter with a spreadsheet of five comparable sales and they adjusted it without me even having to go to a hearing.
avatar
Bg_Pechba
Joined:
31.10.2020
Posts: 964
24.03.2026 01:46
Don't get your hopes up too high. In my experience, they only give small adjustments unless the error is massive.
avatar
simon_v
Joined:
14.11.2021
Posts: 39
05.04.2026 06:59
In reply to a previous post
My neighbor told me that if you appeal, there is a small risk they might look closer and find things that actually increase your value. Is that true?
avatar
Poli_H
Joined:
04.11.2021
Posts: 1659
09.04.2026 08:08
In reply to a previous post
It's rare, but theoretically possible if they realize they missed a square footage addition or a pool. Just make sure your facts are 100% accurate before you file.

Want to join the discussion?

Log in to your account to post a reply in this thread.